Lean Manufacturing in Assembly: Eliminating Waste
Lean principles increase efficiency even in manual assembly. Learn how to identify and eliminate waste.
Lean Manufacturing in Assembly: Eliminating Waste
Lean Manufacturing originated in the automotive industry but is also highly effective in manual precision assembly. At IMS, we have adapted Lean principles and achieve efficiency improvements of 20-40%.
The 7 Types of Waste (Muda)
1. Overproduction
Definition: Producing more than needed
In assembly:
- Too large lot sizes
- Production without concrete order
- "Safety" stocks
Our solution:
- Just-in-time production
- Pull systems
- Kanban for repeat orders
2. Waiting
Definition: Unused time without value creation
Typical causes:
- Missing materials
- Machine failures
- Unbalanced processes
- Approvals
Our solution:
- Optimized material provision
- Poka-yoke systems
- Process balancing
- Interface optimization
3. Unnecessary Transport
Definition: Movement of material without value creation
In assembly:
- Long way between assembly and testing
- Multiple relocations
- Unfavorable layouts
Our solution:
- U-shaped cell organization
- Material at point-of-use
- One-piece flow where possible
4. Over-processing
Definition: Doing more than customer requires
Examples:
- Too tight tolerances
- Unnecessary inspection steps
- Superfluous documentation
Our solution:
- Value stream mapping
- Customer requirement analysis
- Standardization
5. Excess Inventory
Definition: Too much material in stock
Problems:
- Capital tied up
- Obsolescence risk
- Storage costs
- Obsolescence with design changes
Our solution:
- Supplier managed inventory (SMI)
- Consignment warehouse
- Small lot sizes
6. Unnecessary Motion
Definition: Ergonomically unfavorable work steps
Examples:
- Reaching far
- Bending and stretching
- Tool search
- Complicated access
Our solution:
- Ergonomic workstations
- 5S system
- Tools within reach
- Height-adjustable tables
7. Defects and Rework
Definition: Quality defects requiring correction
Costs:
- Direct rework costs
- Time loss
- Demotivation
- Customer complaints
Our solution:
- Poka-yoke (error-proofing)
- Quality at the source
- Immediate response to errors
- Root cause analysis (5-Why)
5S: The Foundation for Lean
1. Sort (Seiri)
- Remove unnecessary items
- Only needed items at workplace
- Regular sorting out
2. Set in Order (Seiton)
- Fixed place for everything
- Shadow boards for tools
- Visual markings
- "One grip" principle
3. Shine (Seiso)
- Keep workplace clean
- Cleaning = inspection
- Detect problems early
4. Standardize (Seiketsu)
- Standards for 1-3
- Visual controls
- Checklists
5. Sustain (Shitsuke)
- Maintain standards
- Continuous improvement
- Audits
At IMS:
- 5S audits weekly
- Visualization everywhere
- Every employee responsible
Value Stream Mapping
Visualize Process
-
Capture current state
- Document all steps
- Measure times
- Identify waste
-
Define future state
- Eliminate waste
- Reduce lead time
- Increase value creation
-
Implementation plan
- Set priorities
- Implement quick wins
- Plan long-term improvements
Practical Example
Current:
- Lead time: 5 days
- Value-added time: 2 hours
- Waiting times: 90%
Future:
- Lead time: 2 days
- Value-added time: 2 hours (same)
- Waiting times: 75% (reduced)
Measures:
- Material closer to assembly
- Parallel instead of sequential testing
- Faster approval processes
Takt Time and Flow Production
Calculate Takt Time
Formula: Takt Time = Available Time / Customer Demand
Example:
- Available time: 8h × 60min = 480 min
- Customer demand: 40 pieces/day
- Takt time: 480 / 40 = 12 min/piece
Meaning: Every 12 minutes a part must be finished.
One-Piece Flow
Advantages:
- Minimal lead time
- Problems immediately visible
- Little work-in-process (WIP)
When possible:
- Balanced process times
- High process stability
- Low setup times
Kaizen: Continuous Improvement
Kaizen Workshops
Format:
- 3-5 days intensive
- Cross-functional team
- Focus on one topic
- Immediate implementation
At IMS:
- 2-3 Kaizen events per year
- Employee suggestions welcome anytime
- Rewards for implemented ideas
PDCA Cycle
Plan:
- Identify problem
- Analyze causes
- Plan solution
Do:
- Implement pilot
- Test
Check:
- Measure results
- Evaluate
Act:
- Standardize
- Look for further potential
Poka-Yoke: Error-Proofing
Examples from Our Practice
Mix-up Protection:
- Different connectors have different colors
- Sensors detect wrong parts
Assembly Aids:
- Asymmetric fixtures
- Only one orientation possible
Counting Aids:
- Provision with exact quantity
- No components should remain
Visual Management
Andon System
Visualization of problems:
- Green: All OK
- Yellow: Support needed
- Red: Production stop
Shopfloor Boards
Daily information:
- Production goals
- Current piece counts
- Quality metrics
- Improvement ideas
KPI Dashboards
Real-time information:
- OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness)
- First-pass yield
- Lead times
- Customer satisfaction
Case Study: 40% Efficiency Increase
Initial Situation:
- Complex assembly, 50 parts
- Assembly time: 45 minutes
- Frequent search times
- Error rate: 2%
Lean Measures:
- 5S at workplace (Week 1)
- Material supermarket set up (Week 2)
- Poka-yoke fixtures (Week 3-4)
- Work instructions optimized (Week 4)
- Training of all assemblers (Week 5)
Result after 2 months:
- Assembly time: 27 minutes (-40%)
- Search times: eliminated
- Error rate: 0.3%
- ROI: 3 months
Lean and Digitalization
Industry 4.0 Meets Lean
Synergies:
- Digital value stream analysis
- Real-time OEE tracking
- Predictive maintenance
- Paperless production
At IMS in implementation:
- Digital work instructions (tablets)
- Barcode scanning for material
- Automatic time recording
- Cloud-based evaluations
Pitfalls and Solutions
Pitfall 1: "Lean is only for large series"
Wrong! Lean principles are universal:
- 5S works everywhere
- Waste exists even at lot size 1
- Standardization helps even with variance
Pitfall 2: "Too expensive to implement"
Counterargument:
- Many Lean measures cost nothing (5S, visual management)
- ROI often in months
- Employee motivation priceless
Pitfall 3: "Employees don't participate"
Solution:
- Involve from the beginning
- Develop improvements together
- Celebrate successes
- Training and education
Conclusion: Lean is a Journey, Not a Destination
Lean Manufacturing is not a one-time action, but a corporate culture. At IMS, we have been living Lean for over 10 years and continuously improve.
Results:
- 30% higher productivity
- 50% less lead time
- 80% fewer errors
- More satisfied employees
Interested in Lean? Visit us for a factory tour and see Lean in action.
About the Author
Markus Weber
Produktionsleiter / Production Manager
Markus optimiert unsere Produktionsprozesse und koordiniert komplexe Montageprojekte mit höchster Effizienz.
