IMS IndustrieMontageService GmbH Logo
Strategy

Make or Buy: When Outsourcing Assembly Makes Sense

Markus Weber
10 min read

Assemble yourself or outsource? A strategic decision with long-term consequences. Learn when outsourcing is the right choice.

Make or Buy: When Outsourcing Assembly Makes Sense

The make-or-buy decision is one of the most important strategic questions for manufacturing companies. When should you assemble yourself, when outsource to specialists like IMS?

Factors for the Make-or-Buy Decision

1. Core Competency

Ask yourself:

  • Is assembly part of our core competency?
  • Do we differentiate ourselves in the market through assembly know-how?
  • Is assembly strategically important for our competitive advantage?

If NO → Consider outsourcing

2. Utilization and Flexibility

In-house assembly requires:

  • Constant utilization (at least 60-70%)
  • Planning for fluctuations
  • Fixed personnel costs

Outsourcing offers:

  • Variable costs
  • Scalability as needed
  • No investments in capacity

3. Quality Requirements

High requirements speak FOR outsourcing to specialists:

  • Medical technology (ISO 13485)
  • Automotive (IATF 16949)
  • Aerospace
  • → Specialized partners have established QM systems

4. Quantities

Rules of thumb:

  • < 500 pieces/year: Almost always outsourcing more economical
  • 500-5,000 pieces/year: Case-by-case consideration
  • > 5,000 pieces/year: In-house can make sense

5. Complexity

High complexity:

  • Many individual parts (> 30)
  • Different joining techniques
  • Special tools required
  • → Specialist often better

Low complexity:

  • Few standard steps
  • Simple tools
  • Little know-how needed
  • → In-house possible

Cost Comparison: In-House vs. Outsourcing

In-House Costs (often underestimated)

Direct costs:

  • Wages assemblers (€40,000-60,000/year)
  • Social contributions (approx. +30%)
  • Tools and fixtures (€2,000-20,000)
  • Test equipment (€5,000-50,000)
  • Workplace equipment (€3,000-10,000/place)

Indirect costs:

  • Production planning and control
  • Quality assurance
  • Warehousing
  • Space (rent, utilities)
  • Administrative effort
  • Training

Hidden costs:

  • Vacation coverage
  • Sick leave
  • Turnover and onboarding
  • Investments in new technologies
  • Maintenance

Realistic total costs: €80,000-120,000/workplace/year

Outsourcing Costs

Direct costs:

  • Assembly costs per piece
  • Transport
  • Possibly tool costs (one-time)

Advantages:

  • No fixed costs
  • Scalable
  • Transparent

Hidden Benefits of Outsourcing

1. Focus on Core Business

Your resources can concentrate on:

  • Product development
  • Sales
  • Customer projects
  • Innovation

Instead of:

  • Production planning
  • Personnel scheduling
  • Tool procurement
  • Quality problems in assembly

2. Access to Expertise

A specialized assembly service provider offers:

  • 30+ years of team experience (like at IMS)
  • Assembly specialists with 10+ years experience
  • Proven processes
  • Tested quality systems

3. Risk Minimization

Risks you avoid:

  • Personnel failure
  • Quality problems from untrained employees
  • Technology investments that don't amortize
  • Overcapacity during order downturns

4. Faster Time-to-Market

Outsourcing enables:

  • Immediate start (no personnel buildup)
  • No learning curve
  • Established processes
  • Experience from similar projects

When In-House Assembly Makes Sense

Strategic Reasons

  1. Core competency: Assembly is your USP
  2. Confidentiality: Extremely sensitive know-how
  3. Integration: Assembly is closely interwoven with design/development
  4. Customer proximity: Assembly is part of customer experience

Economic Reasons

  1. High quantities: > 10,000/year with stable utilization
  2. Standardized processes: Simple, repetitive assembly
  3. Available capacities: Free production space and personnel

Case Study: Right Outsourcing Decision

Company: Mid-sized machine builder
Product: Control unit for special machines
Quantity: 300 pieces/year

Initial situation:

  • Assembly in own workshop
  • 1.5 employees (full-time equivalent)
  • Problems: Vacation times, quality variations
  • High lead times

Decision for outsourcing to IMS:

After 1 year:

  • Costs: -15% (despite higher unit price)
  • Quality: Error rate from 3% to 0.5%
  • Lead time: from 3 weeks to 5 days
  • Resources freed: 1.5 employees moved to sales

Additional benefits:

  • Customer can now accept express orders
  • No worries about personnel failure
  • DFM feedback improved product design

Hybrid Model: The Best of Both Worlds

Possible combinations:

Model 1: Standard vs. Special

  • Standard variants: In-house
  • Special variants and small series: Outsourcing

Model 2: Capacity Extension

  • Base capacity: In-house
  • Peak loads and special orders: Outsourcing

Model 3: Development vs. Series

  • Prototypes and pre-series: Outsourcing (flexibility)
  • Large series: In-house (after process optimization)

Risks in Outsourcing (and how to avoid them)

Risk 1: Dependency on Supplier

Avoidance:

  • Clear contracts with service level agreements (SLA)
  • Qualify second source (for critical products)
  • Maintain own know-how (documentation, visits)

Risk 2: Know-how Loss

Avoidance:

  • Keep technical documentation
  • Regular exchange with service provider
  • Let employees occasionally work along

Risk 3: Quality Problems

Avoidance:

  • Clear specifications
  • Regular audits
  • First Article Inspection (FAI)
  • Continuous exchange

Risk 4: IP Protection

Avoidance:

  • Non-disclosure agreements (NDA)
  • Selection of trustworthy partners
  • Keep critical processes in-house if necessary

Choosing the Right Partner

Selection Criteria for Assembly Service Providers

Must-have criteria:

  • Relevant experience in your industry
  • Quality management system (ISO 9001 or better)
  • References from comparable projects
  • Financial stability

Nice-to-have criteria:

  • Regional proximity
  • Flexibility in quantities and deadlines
  • Consulting competence (DFM)
  • Additional services (procurement, logistics)

IMS Advantages:

  • 30+ years of team experience
  • working in accordance with ISO 9001
  • Rhine-Main region (short distances)
  • DFM consulting included
  • Flexible lot sizes (1-10,000 pieces)

Decision Aid: Checklist

Outsourcing is probably the better choice if:

  • ✓ Assembly is not your core competency
  • ✓ Quantities < 1,000/year
  • ✓ Fluctuating demands
  • ✓ High quality requirements
  • ✓ Fast market entry important
  • ✓ No free capacities
  • ✓ Specialist knowledge required
  • ✓ Focus on other topics desired

In-house might be better if:

  • ✓ Assembly is strategic core competency
  • ✓ Quantities > 5,000/year (stable)
  • ✓ Simple, standardized processes
  • ✓ Existing overcapacity
  • ✓ Extremely sensitive know-how
  • ✓ Close integration with development necessary

Conclusion: A Strategic Decision

The make-or-buy decision is complex and individual. Generally:

  • Small series and complex assemblies → Outsourcing
  • Large series and simple processes → Consider in-house
  • Growing companies → Outsourcing for flexibility

At IMS we have experience with both scenarios:

  • Customers who outsource permanently (more economical)
  • Customers who start with us and later go in-house (larger quantities)

Free consultation: Send us your drawings and quantity framework – we'll create a make-or-buy analysis for your specific case.

About the Author

Markus Weber

Produktionsleiter / Production Manager

Markus optimiert unsere Produktionsprozesse und koordiniert komplexe Montageprojekte mit höchster Effizienz.

Topics

Outsourcing
Make or Buy
Cost Calculation
Strategy

Do you have questions about this topic?

Contact us for a non-binding consultation.