Make or Buy: When Outsourcing Assembly Makes Sense
Assemble yourself or outsource? A strategic decision with long-term consequences. Learn when outsourcing is the right choice.
Make or Buy: When Outsourcing Assembly Makes Sense
The make-or-buy decision is one of the most important strategic questions for manufacturing companies. When should you assemble yourself, when outsource to specialists like IMS?
Factors for the Make-or-Buy Decision
1. Core Competency
Ask yourself:
- Is assembly part of our core competency?
- Do we differentiate ourselves in the market through assembly know-how?
- Is assembly strategically important for our competitive advantage?
If NO → Consider outsourcing
2. Utilization and Flexibility
In-house assembly requires:
- Constant utilization (at least 60-70%)
- Planning for fluctuations
- Fixed personnel costs
Outsourcing offers:
- Variable costs
- Scalability as needed
- No investments in capacity
3. Quality Requirements
High requirements speak FOR outsourcing to specialists:
- Medical technology (ISO 13485)
- Automotive (IATF 16949)
- Aerospace
- → Specialized partners have established QM systems
4. Quantities
Rules of thumb:
- < 500 pieces/year: Almost always outsourcing more economical
- 500-5,000 pieces/year: Case-by-case consideration
- > 5,000 pieces/year: In-house can make sense
5. Complexity
High complexity:
- Many individual parts (> 30)
- Different joining techniques
- Special tools required
- → Specialist often better
Low complexity:
- Few standard steps
- Simple tools
- Little know-how needed
- → In-house possible
Cost Comparison: In-House vs. Outsourcing
In-House Costs (often underestimated)
Direct costs:
- Wages assemblers (€40,000-60,000/year)
- Social contributions (approx. +30%)
- Tools and fixtures (€2,000-20,000)
- Test equipment (€5,000-50,000)
- Workplace equipment (€3,000-10,000/place)
Indirect costs:
- Production planning and control
- Quality assurance
- Warehousing
- Space (rent, utilities)
- Administrative effort
- Training
Hidden costs:
- Vacation coverage
- Sick leave
- Turnover and onboarding
- Investments in new technologies
- Maintenance
Realistic total costs: €80,000-120,000/workplace/year
Outsourcing Costs
Direct costs:
- Assembly costs per piece
- Transport
- Possibly tool costs (one-time)
Advantages:
- No fixed costs
- Scalable
- Transparent
Hidden Benefits of Outsourcing
1. Focus on Core Business
Your resources can concentrate on:
- Product development
- Sales
- Customer projects
- Innovation
Instead of:
- Production planning
- Personnel scheduling
- Tool procurement
- Quality problems in assembly
2. Access to Expertise
A specialized assembly service provider offers:
- 30+ years of team experience (like at IMS)
- Assembly specialists with 10+ years experience
- Proven processes
- Tested quality systems
3. Risk Minimization
Risks you avoid:
- Personnel failure
- Quality problems from untrained employees
- Technology investments that don't amortize
- Overcapacity during order downturns
4. Faster Time-to-Market
Outsourcing enables:
- Immediate start (no personnel buildup)
- No learning curve
- Established processes
- Experience from similar projects
When In-House Assembly Makes Sense
Strategic Reasons
- Core competency: Assembly is your USP
- Confidentiality: Extremely sensitive know-how
- Integration: Assembly is closely interwoven with design/development
- Customer proximity: Assembly is part of customer experience
Economic Reasons
- High quantities: > 10,000/year with stable utilization
- Standardized processes: Simple, repetitive assembly
- Available capacities: Free production space and personnel
Case Study: Right Outsourcing Decision
Company: Mid-sized machine builder
Product: Control unit for special machines
Quantity: 300 pieces/year
Initial situation:
- Assembly in own workshop
- 1.5 employees (full-time equivalent)
- Problems: Vacation times, quality variations
- High lead times
Decision for outsourcing to IMS:
After 1 year:
- Costs: -15% (despite higher unit price)
- Quality: Error rate from 3% to 0.5%
- Lead time: from 3 weeks to 5 days
- Resources freed: 1.5 employees moved to sales
Additional benefits:
- Customer can now accept express orders
- No worries about personnel failure
- DFM feedback improved product design
Hybrid Model: The Best of Both Worlds
Possible combinations:
Model 1: Standard vs. Special
- Standard variants: In-house
- Special variants and small series: Outsourcing
Model 2: Capacity Extension
- Base capacity: In-house
- Peak loads and special orders: Outsourcing
Model 3: Development vs. Series
- Prototypes and pre-series: Outsourcing (flexibility)
- Large series: In-house (after process optimization)
Risks in Outsourcing (and how to avoid them)
Risk 1: Dependency on Supplier
Avoidance:
- Clear contracts with service level agreements (SLA)
- Qualify second source (for critical products)
- Maintain own know-how (documentation, visits)
Risk 2: Know-how Loss
Avoidance:
- Keep technical documentation
- Regular exchange with service provider
- Let employees occasionally work along
Risk 3: Quality Problems
Avoidance:
- Clear specifications
- Regular audits
- First Article Inspection (FAI)
- Continuous exchange
Risk 4: IP Protection
Avoidance:
- Non-disclosure agreements (NDA)
- Selection of trustworthy partners
- Keep critical processes in-house if necessary
Choosing the Right Partner
Selection Criteria for Assembly Service Providers
Must-have criteria:
- Relevant experience in your industry
- Quality management system (ISO 9001 or better)
- References from comparable projects
- Financial stability
Nice-to-have criteria:
- Regional proximity
- Flexibility in quantities and deadlines
- Consulting competence (DFM)
- Additional services (procurement, logistics)
IMS Advantages:
- 30+ years of team experience
- working in accordance with ISO 9001
- Rhine-Main region (short distances)
- DFM consulting included
- Flexible lot sizes (1-10,000 pieces)
Decision Aid: Checklist
Outsourcing is probably the better choice if:
- ✓ Assembly is not your core competency
- ✓ Quantities < 1,000/year
- ✓ Fluctuating demands
- ✓ High quality requirements
- ✓ Fast market entry important
- ✓ No free capacities
- ✓ Specialist knowledge required
- ✓ Focus on other topics desired
In-house might be better if:
- ✓ Assembly is strategic core competency
- ✓ Quantities > 5,000/year (stable)
- ✓ Simple, standardized processes
- ✓ Existing overcapacity
- ✓ Extremely sensitive know-how
- ✓ Close integration with development necessary
Conclusion: A Strategic Decision
The make-or-buy decision is complex and individual. Generally:
- Small series and complex assemblies → Outsourcing
- Large series and simple processes → Consider in-house
- Growing companies → Outsourcing for flexibility
At IMS we have experience with both scenarios:
- Customers who outsource permanently (more economical)
- Customers who start with us and later go in-house (larger quantities)
Free consultation: Send us your drawings and quantity framework – we'll create a make-or-buy analysis for your specific case.
About the Author
Markus Weber
Produktionsleiter / Production Manager
Markus optimiert unsere Produktionsprozesse und koordiniert komplexe Montageprojekte mit höchster Effizienz.
